- Heroes has fallen into a standard trap that has made many a sci-fi show “jump the shark.” Time travel. Time travel ruins pretty much any show that tries to play with it (except Doctor Who, but he doesn’t use it as a tool, just a device to get from plot to plot). The worst part is once you start using time travel it becomes the cause and solution to all of your problems.
Here is what I suggest: find some way (no matter how contrived and silly) to remove all backward time travel. ALL OF IT. Ok, Hiro becomes a little less cool – he now can teleport (still cool) and slow down or speed up his (any maybe a few others in close proximity) transit through time (ie the world isn’t stopping – he is just moving more slowly through it).
If you want to do big apocalyptic episodes you can always use oracles (Isaac Menendez style – they have predictions that are never quite clear). - Characters who get powers only get one power with maybe a couple of corollary powers (some people never get them ...see Xander Harris from Buffy).
Examples:- Clair can heal any non-head traumas – her blood can do the same to others.
- Nikki is strong and tough
- Nathan can fly
- Cop-Guy can read minds
- Annoying girl can cause disease (maybe she learns to cure them too).
That leaves Peter and Sylar .... They just can’t exist; they are too powerful. Their power level is completely unbounded - anything you want them to be able to do, they can. They are not only walking deus ex machina they overshadow everyone else; it is no longer an ensemble cast it is the Sylar and Peter show. It is akin to putting Brad Pitt in a community theater production. No matter how good Mich Gruberman is, if he is on stage with Brad he will only get noticed if he screws up.
Peter is fixable – make him an empathic (yes, give him the new power to read emotions, but not minds) and make him able to emulate any power he is around...but make the powers fade after a time. Powers that he is around more and more often he gets to keep longer – leave him alone in a cell for a month and he only gets empathy.
Sylar – sorry, I love the actor and the way the character is constructed but he had his season. I would love to see him broken back into all of the awesome characters that got only one episode: Memory girl (that Hiro fell in love with), Super-Hearing chick, Melty guy.
Everyone has to be obviously killable or it is no fun. This also means people have to work together to do cool things. Superman was never as cool as the Cyclops+Wolverine fastball special. - Limit the use of duplicated powers. Only use it as a foil to the main character. Nathan can fly, we don’t need Clair’s BF to fly too. Yes, the writers need to work harder – poor writers. I can see using it to show how the same power can be used for good or evil; maybe to give somebody a “if not for the grace of god” moment, but a lot of that can be done by the actually character turning evil or being possessed.
- Bring back the paltry mundane lives of the characters. They all have to make rent, have lovers, and do stuff outside of the heroic world. Hiro is a true hero, the others should get back to just trying to make it in the world. This way when everyone converges on <location> for the season finally it is special.



